Field Office Compliance - Assistance


Assistance ID - 100076
Winnebago Industries, Inc - Forest City - 310270292
605 W CRYSTAL LAKE RD Forest City, IA
Winnebago County

FO 2

Report
File Name File Type File Date Note
Comments
4/12/2018 From: Miller, David <[email protected]> Date: Thu, Apr 12, 2018 at 9:24 AM Subject: NPDES Permit Rtionale To: Wayne Venzke <[email protected]> Wayne – This email responds to your recent question on Steve Williams’ March 30, 2004, rationale memo for Winnebago’s NPDES Permit. My understanding of your question is paraphrased below: “If dilution cannot be used to meet effluent limits, why did Mr. Williams, in the 3rd paragraph of page 2, seem to use dilution of oil & grease as a rationale?” This paragraph is under the heading “Outfall 001”, and Mr. Williams states that “Even if the company discharged oil & grease at the maximum allowable concentrations from both Outfalls 801 and 802 the concentration in the lagoon after mixing with domestic sewage and cooling water would be 2.7 mg/l.” He goes on to say that this concentration of oil & grease would not pose a risk to the receiving stream. Mr. Williams was not using dilution as a rationale for meeting a limit, rather he was using mixing as a rationale for not establishing a limit. I would paraphrase his rationale as follows: “I am not setting an oil & grease limit for Outfall 001 because the oil & grease limits on Outfalls 801 and 802 are sufficient, after mixing, to protect the receiving stream.” Please contact me if you have any additional questions regarding this matter. David Miller | Environmental Specialist Senior DAVID MILLER